November 19 2010
Can Your Facebook Page Be Used Against You In Your Kentucky Accident Case?
Tagged Under : attorney, automobile accidents, car wreck, Facebook, insurance adjuster, kentucky, personal injury, social media, Twitter
Every one is tweeting on Twitter and posting on Facebook. We are walking down the street with our smart phones checking out our friends. Social media is everywhere. Employers have been looking at these sites for years to determine whether or not to hire somebody. What happens if someone injured in a Kentucky car wreck posts on Facebook? Who can look at it? Is it just who you want to look at your posts?
Defense attorneys and insurance adjusters have been looking at social media sites to get information on YOU in an attempt to deny or limit your recovery in your personal injury claim. This is whether it is from an auto accident, bicycle accident or dog bite.
It is only a matter of time before Kentucky courts start to hear cases on social networking sites. Courts in other states have already made rulings on social media issues. Here is the question. Are Kentucky Courts going to force an accident victim to give access to their social networking sites to the attorney who represents the person that hit you? The answer is not clear at this point in time.
Here are some points that Courts in other states have looked at. One question involves privacy settings. Just because you make something private is it really private to the Courts? Will checking the private box be a barrier to the defense seeing what you posted? By making settings on my account private I do not intend for everyone to see what I have posted or what is on my profile. Colorado Courts have allowed Wal Mart to subpoena information from Facebook, MySpace and Meetup because they felt the information sought was relevant and reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible information. This is legalize for we don’t know if it has anything to do with the case but it might.
Courts have allowed defendants to view social media postings in a variety of situations. In a case where a child had an eating disorder the court said that information posted on a social networking site may show that the disorder came from something other than what is alleged in the lawsuit. So the plaintiff had to turn over access to the site to the at-fault party and their insurance company.
In Connecticut the Court allowed a defendant to view Facebook accounts stating that it was a snapshot of the plaintiff’s state of mind at the time they were harmed. New Jersey has a similar ruling. This is disturbing to personal injury attorneys and Kentucky automobile accident victims. If this standard is adopted in Kentucky just about any fact situation in any accident would lead to the court allowing the at-fault party’s attorney and insurance company to look at your Facebook page.
Courts in jurisdictions, including California, have concluded that by posting online you have acknowledged that the information you are giving is not intended to be private no matter what the privacy settings are in place on your account. If you post it on the internet and you are involved in a lawsuit they are going to let the other side see it.
This means that accident victims must be very careful about what is posted. A recent California case found that private Facebook and MySpace communications between individuals could not be subpoenaed. So maybe your wall postings are safe, maybe not.
To date there has been no cases heard in the Kentucky Courts. We do not know what will happen in Kentucky. Caution is in order. Be CAREFUL! Here are a few tips:
- Look at your privacy settings and set them to block anyone other than people you know from viewing your site.
- Do not post anything that discusses your lawsuit or accident case.
- Do not discuss your injuries in your postings.
- Do not post photographs of you attempting or doing any physical activity that you are now unable to do as a result of your injuries from the accident.
- Make sure your friends don’t post any of the above.
- Do not accept friend invitations from anyone you don’t know. They could be working for the other side!
- Take a look at your friend list. Remove anybody that you don’t know.
Just be smart so that information posted on social media sites can’t be twisted and used to make you look untruthful or not injured. Taking these simple steps will help prevent unwanted information getting to the other side and maximizing the value of your Kentucky accident case.



