July 01 2011
Medicare, State Farm and Your Accident Case
Tagged Under : car accident, insurance settlement, kentucky, lien, medical bills, medicare, personal injury attorney, PIP, Stae Farm, uninsured motorist coverage
Steven Wilson was the passenger of a Jeep Grand Cherokee and was insured by State Farm. The car was involved in an injury car accident on August 29, 2009. Unfortunately, the driver of the other vehicle who was at fault was uninsured. Wilson had significant medical bills due to the accident. Some of these medical bills were paid by the Medicare (This is the practice in Kentucky after the PIP benefits are exhausted. The payment creates a statutory lien requiring the recipient of the Medicare benefits to repay Medicare. This is called a super lien because the attorney and the insurance company are also liable if payment is not made). The State Farm insurance policy available to Wilson was an uninsured motorist policy. The policy limits were only $50,000.
State Farm asked permission to discuss the lien with the Medicare. This was refused by Wilson. Wilson then demanded the insurance settlement be deposited in an attorney escrow account. State Farm suggested including Medicare as a payee on the settlement check which was also rejected by Wilson. Eventually, State Farm issued separate checks to Medicare and Wilson while waiting for Medicare’s determination of the value of its lien.
Dealing with Medicare is frustrating for accident victims as well as their personal injury attorney. They are typically slow in responding to lien amounts which will hold up finalizing a personal injury settlement. Unfortunately, there is nothing that can be done to speed up the process. Patience is the key.
In Wilson v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company Co, Steven Wilson claims State Farm acted in bad faith by delaying payment of the policy limits more than 30 days. According to the Courts opinion State Farm learned the value of the Medicare lien after two months when they paid both the Medicare and Wilson.
Judge John G. Heyburn, II signed a Memorandum Opinion and Order on June 14, 2011 granting State Farm’s motion for summary judgment and dismissing the complaint with prejudice. Wilson’s motion for summary judgment was also denied. The Court concluded that delay or withholding of payment until a determination is made with respect to Medicare’s conditional payment amount alone does not constitute bad faith. State Farm had the willingness to settle its accounts. The fact that they attempted to determine the amount to be paid to Medicare was considered a reasonable precaution to protect itself from overpayment.
Under Kentucky law in order to withhold payment on an insurance claim the insurance company must:
- Have an obligation to pay the claim;
- Not have a reasonable basis for failing to pay the claim; and
- Know that it lacked a reasonable basis to delay payment or act in a reckless disregard to the existence of the basis.
Although I understand the Court’s ruling, I see this opinion being used to delay payments in accident cases. This will allow the insurance company to hold onto the settlement amount and earn interest while the injured accident victim struggles to make ends meet. Surely there is a better way.



